Let me ask a question to all. What guidline would you like to see used to decide if a song should be sung?

I do not want to be to broad so I will give examples:

1) No song associated with minstrelsy should ever be played even if no direct mention of race is present.

2) Songs should only be sung if all racial material is removed. O Susanna with the second verse (see above is dropped or modified) removed

3) Only famous or important songs that demonstrate shifts in American music should be used but not the most offensive and never those of no musical value. ie The Wedding of the Chinee and the Coon (this would never be played)

4) All songs are fair game with the proviso that the song in question is well explained as to meaning. This could mean that if the only meaning is pure racism; it should be dealt with as such. This level should be restricted to the college classroom.

5) No restrictions at all. Music is music.

I must say right now, I am not trying to provoke anyone. I want to clarify that which has been said already. Some of the posts here have been a bit unclear OR contradictory. I just want to fully understand.

In self defense, I am also NOT looking for an answer from any single person, I hope to get many answers from many people.

Last--- Susan how was your weekend?

George