Fibula - I have to agree there is a touch of the hound scenting the hare in some of the posts since your original, most useful contribution. But I am assuming music is not yet a blood sport. I have greatly enjoyed reading Mr Hannon's posts. But the discussion would benefit from some input from the Toome fishermen. As another noted Irishman, George Bernard Shaw, put it - the best way to get to the merits of any case is to hear it argued with extreme bias on either side. Larry, as a former judge, would probably go along with that.