One reason for retuning in old time fiddle tunes is that they use a fair amout of cross tunings (i.e. "open tunings) (AEAE, AEAC#, ADAE, ADAD, I've even heard D'DAF#). This isn't just for laziness in fingering; not only are drop-notes and drones possible without having octopus fingers and perfect pitch, but even if the string is not bowed, you get harmonic resonance in these strings which changes tonal quality. This really adds to the "sound" of the old-time fiddle, where the tunes are more centered on the key and not given to the flights of fancy that are more common common in the bluegrass realm. In other cultures, open tunings are more common as well. Norwegian hardingfeles have not only open tuning, but additional sympathetic strings for even more resonance. But there they do take to "flights of fancy" at times, modulating the key (and the rythm; they came make a 3/4 on paper into something approaching a 5/4 time) and even getting into semitones and such. Perhaps the drones and sympathetic strings serve to remind them how to get back to where they came from. . . . ;-) I suspect a lot of the cross tuning tradition in old-time fiddling comes from its closer relationship with its prior roots in Celtic music than is true of bluegrass. Cheers, -- Arne Langsetmo
|