Charisma is indeed an undefinable quality, and the most talented musicians are not always the most charismatic.

In my young life up to date, the most charismatic performer I have ever seen, by some way, was David Bromberg. I am quite sure that anyone who saw him at his peak would agree with me.

Yet there were better guitarists around at the time (Dick Fegy who played in the Bromberg Band being one) and there were certainly better singers.

Bromberg however had (and may still have for all I know)) an unbelievable stage presence which far transcended his musical abilities.

Murray