After reading all these threads, it seems that the prevailing theme is "different strokes for different folks". (Sorry Sly!) I'm seeing notes from people who love new songs, people who love songs with chorus singing, songs without instrumentation, diverse cultures, "name" performers, "unknown" performers, and every permutation in between.

I think this thread shows the beauty and depth of folk music. Instead of moaning the festivals that no longer program the music we feel appropriate, perhaps we should be throwing more support to the festivals that do. I know it is tough for a musician when they feel the door is shut, but perhaps they are looking in the wrong places. You can't stop evolution. Festivals are run by individuals. These individuals are judged on their performance.   Perhaps the best way to vote is to support the festival of your choice.