I saw it on Saturday (with Ms L) and, despite my usual scepticism was impressed by both the historical and textual accuracy. The effect of the shot in the battle scenes was particularly impressive, and I found the amputation of Blakeney's arm (Ms L couldn't watch!)and the death of his friend in the boarding quite moving.

On the debit side, the ship was once or twice seen to be 'sailing' at several knots with no waves, virtually no wind and a distinct propeller wake! And why was Bonden (the boatswain, if I remember rightly) at the wheel so often? And why did Aubrey take the wheel from him or from the quartermaster...

...But on the whole, very impressive and a good evening out. I must now re-read the books!

Steve