Each film had a small disappointment for me. I didn't like Galadriel. She should have been so beautiful that it hurt to look at her. I didn't think much of the Ents, and I wish they'd marched off singing "Though Isengard be strong and hard etc."
I as annoyed that they just left Saurman in Isengard among the Ents. I would have liked a little more of Eowyn. It annoyed me that they clapped when Aragorn was crowned. (Small, I know, but there you are.) I wish Jackson had spent a little less time on Mt. Doom.

AND THEN I found myself torn apart as Frodo sailed to the Gray Havens. I lived and breathed those books when I was a girl, and the ending tore me up. I don't know if I was mourning the passing of the age, or the passing of my youth.