Now the idea of a separate thread about the concerns raised by Shambles might make sense, but the heading by Amergin is pointlessly provocative. The paradox is that this is just the kind of thread title that tends to get threads yanked, but clearly Shambles would be against that happening.

However I think the heading I've put in over this post would be an improvement. (And my answer to the question I raise there would be "No, but it's not a silly question")