The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #67974   Message #1141082
Posted By: Les in Chorlton
19-Mar-04 - 01:41 PM
Thread Name: Would you sing Peggy and the Soldier
Subject: RE: Would you sing Peggy and the Soldier
"My view would be to drop it and upset the piper (he who pays)".

People who are offended by old songs don't generally pay anything much.

To be fair I think my original question has been well explored in the thoughtful way that these threads do.

Self cencorship in a climate of intollerance is worst than cencorship from powers that be. But that's not the issue.

I sing the song The Beggar - Dave Burland et al. It contains the line:

Neither Jew nor Turk will make me work whilst begging is as good as it is.

I feel it inappropriate to explain the historical significance and then distance myself. I simply sing

Their's no one who will make me work.......

I bit of history is lost but my country, my community, my folk club and my circle of friends include 'Jews and Turks'.

A very large number of women have been victims of male violence and I don't think we should sing songs without considering the historical context of that experience as well as that of the songs.