Very uncanny, as my wife just last week was trying to remember what turned out to be Bonomo's Turkish Taffy. There was a web site about old fashioned candy that helped us remember this stuff. Turns out, it was bought out by Tootise Roll here in Chicago and has not been made since the late '80s. She had such a jones for it!

Charlston Chew is very close and was able to satisfy the crave.