Sian, Thank you for the info, I have got two tunes in ABC format and I'll put them up here as soon as I have every detail right. That is: can you trawl through the 25 Journals again and give me the Date, Issue Number, and if possible Page Number of the Journal of Welsh Folklore Society that contain:
1. the John Thomas tune you mentioned on 16 Jun 04. Did not you say it was in an article by Phyllis Kinney on Plygian carol tunes? Was that in the Journal?
2. the other tune, from British Harmony, that was in a Cass Meurig article on fiddle playing in the C18th. Was that a 2001 Journal?
Or have I got them the wrong was round?
Sorry to be tedious but the scholars want this very much as it's the only way they can tell if these tunes are real. So many of the ABCs around have neither provenance nor reference. So how can we ever look them up to find out anything more about them?