The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #71751   Message #1229642
Posted By: Joe Offer
20-Jul-04 - 04:03 AM
Thread Name: BS: We're not against the soldiers.
Subject: RE: BS: We're not against the soldiers.
I've been opposed to the war in Iraq since the idea of it first hit the news. A number of times, people have chided me for "not supporting our troops." They see very clearly that those who oppose the war are detrimental to our soldiers in numerous ways - it hurts morale on "our side" and gives hope to our opponents. They say that since I don't support my country's war effort, I don't love my country. Oh, and they also accuse me of "disrespecting the President."

I suppose this is logic that has been used in every war since Cain slew Abel - and I suppose I have to say there's an element of truth in that logic. If "supporting our troops" means helping them win an unjust war, then I guess I don't support them. If "love of country" means that I mustn't criticize our leaders when they are unjust, then I guess I don't love my country. I can't say I agree with that logic, but I guess I have to admit that it makes sense on the surface.

So, what's a good way to refute that sort of logic in words a talk-show audience can understand? I have to say that in the area where I live, I'm afraid to put an anti-war bumper sticker on my car. Those who support the war are very angry at us who do not - and I like my pretty red car. I didn't mind getting fingers flipped at me when I marched for peace - but I don't want my car vandalized.

-Joe Offer-