There've been a couple of mentions of Santa Cruz models already on this thread. The OM-PW CLICK is the least expensive 'Cruz and it'll hold its own against much more expensive guitars. It's not a fancy guitar, but it is beautiful in a minimalist fashion. It's sensitive enough for pretty fingerpicking, but loud and solid enough for rhythm work like backing up fiddlers.

Note: The guitar on Elderly's website has Waverly tuners. Elderly usually also carries them with cheaper Grover tuners for about $150 USD less. They seem to be out of them at the moment.