When I learned it back in the early 60's it was:

Five Foot Nine, Looks divine
Says he comes from Palestine
Has anybody seen my Lord?

Long brown hair... Button Nose
Hebrew? Yep he's one of those...
Has anybody seen my Lord?

Well if you run into a five foot Jew...
Don't nail him down...
He's so neat.. He's so cool... He can save your town...

Virgin Mary she's the most
She got laid by the Holy Ghost
Has anybody seen my Lord...
Just hanging round now...
Has anybody seen my Lord...