On The Corries' 'Silver Collection' the Rose of Allendale is given to be by Nelson/Jeffreys/arr by B/W and the two Irish Roses of A. that I have (one by Mary Black) are trad, melody being slightly different from the Scottish one.

Moreover, I've seen Rose of Tralee been mentioned to be by E.M. Spencer & C.W. Glover (words and music).

Another couple of 'Scarborough Fairs by PS' or what is this all about, anybody know??

AKS on a grey Monday morning