The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #78025   Message #1401322
Posted By: GUEST,GUEST,Belfast/N.I./Ireland
07-Feb-05 - 12:06 AM
Thread Name: BS: Are SF fascist at heart
Subject: RE: BS: Are SF fascist at heart
Who bothered to read the posted links, one of them contain the reason why Sean Russell went to Hitler for help, it mentions he has no time for his killing of Jews etc.

To debate anything about Ireland turns into what aboutery, like ard brought up combat 18, relevance to the original question is none.

We have to be able to look at what we allow to to or aspire to govern us in it's true light and in the case of SF/IRA many do not.

When we have a political party willing to go to any means to gain it's objective surely someone who supports that party has to question it actions.

The Hitler connection was a perfect example as to the self destructive lengths some people would go. This is not healthy to any side of the divide, because I for one do not believe that people would have been happy with a united Ireland brought about with help from Hitler.

The death of one nation,Jewish, to liberate another Ireland is a decision that should not be taken by one political party. SF's action would have led to the death of countless many and as people here see themselves as humanists,would such a price be acceptable to you. That would you be happy to know that Ireland was united but whatever Jewish population and traveller population it had would be gassed.


As for the mistake of 70 years ago, that would be a reasonable arguement if SF/IRA had not sought assistance from present day despots, Libya,Irag,Iran etc. They still keep to the same basic premise, use anyone to obtain our aim and to hell with the consequences.

What I am asking at what cost freedom and the answer seems to be at the cost of others. Would Nat/rep be at ease with this. I know I would not and I do want a United Ireland, but not at the cost of others in the world.

Call this a troll if you want or maybe or as many insecure rep put "propaganda".