The first part is definitely closed to Road to Dundee than Bard of Armagh but there is a close similarity between the two tunes so I reckon we'll never know for sure what Mudguard is hearing. I'll be in Rothenburg ob der Tauber in Whitsun for the beer festival but as one rarely eats over the three days, I guess the offer of a free dineer is superfluous! If Mudguard can make it to Rothenburg o d T, we could have a drink together. I'll probably be travelling with Nigel Denver who could sing all the different versions of those/that tune.