Yeah, that sort of fits, with a little nipping and tucking here and there. Thanks!

In searching, it seems that there have been a number of both old and contemporary pieces given the same title - even by a couple of rock bands, one of which has an album by that name.

Of course during the early 1800s it was common for lyrics and tunes to be randomly connected by meter, apparently at the whim of the Choir Director or Pastor. A lot of familiar Hymns today were not commonly associated as to lyrics and score until after the Civil War. Some Hymnals still contain a "Metrical Index" for those who like to mix and match.

As an example, the setting for the 39th Psalm by Issac WATTS works well with the score for the Navy Hymn.

Fortunately, I'll be playing "Arise" on the fife, and not be expected to sing it!