The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #81179 Message #1485645
Posted By: Azizi
15-May-05 - 06:31 PM
Thread Name: African American Secular Folk Songs
Subject: RE: African American Secular Folk Songs
Here are my responses in brackets to WYSIWYG's 15 May 05 - 05:48 PM
"..it would at least be very helpful if each time a song is posted in this thread, there is first a search to see if other variants are already posted"
"It's also important (according to the FAQ as well as Joe's recent posts in the Help forum), that when a song is added in any thread, the post's subject line is changed to refelct the added song, for example:
ADD: Nine Pound Hammer"
[Alright. And I will ask Joe Offer to add that to those posts that I have already written in this thread]
"Before it makes sense to start move forward with indexing secular AA material in the spirituals permathread, I'd like to hear Azizi's contribution to the just-begun discussion about that indexing, in the permathread..]"
[I have previously asked you to provide a link in this thread to that African American spiritual Permathread. I will be pleased to read the comments posted and respond to them as I expect others may want to do also].
"..I'd like to help Azizi in her present effort, but I am not sure yet how she sees her project shaping up or if she wants or would appreciate any help."
[I guess that depends on the definition of "help". LOL! But seriously though see the comments that I have made in this thread thus far:
"I am creating this separate thread because it is a subject I am very concerned about. Because two posters to that other thread commented on my posts about this subject, this may also be a subject that could be of interests to others.
I am interested in knowing whether you think it is appropriate and/or important to include information that is known about the racial/ethnic origin of folk songs.
I also would like to know if others have noted inconsistencies in how folk songs are categorized in music books.
And I would also be interested in any help that could be given in listing and providing documention of American folk songs that are considered to be of African American origin or probable African American origin.
Thank you. " 14 May 05 - 12:37 AM
"It is my hope that I will not be alone in responding to the critical question "What counts as sufficient evidence that an item should be classified as "African American Secular folk song?"...
"Again, I would very much welcome your thoughts on what guidelines should be used to categorize a song as a secular African American folk song." Date: 14 May 05 - 10:17 AM
"Needless to say, I very much welcome comments on the subject of African American secular folk songs from other 'Catters and from Guests." 15 May 05 - 11:47 AM.
However, I am a bit curious at what WYSIWYG meand by Mudcat Elders. Definition please. Thank you. And thanks also for the link to the Origins Permathead. I will check it out]