The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #59418 Message #1489087
Posted By: GUEST,MMario
20-May-05 - 09:10 AM
Thread Name: BS: The Mother of all BS threads
Subject: RE: BS: The Mother of all BS threads
•Whenever a spreader meets an ignorant, the ignorant becomes a spreader, while the original spreader continues spreading.
•When a spreader meets a stifler, the spreader becomes a stifler.
•In the case where two spreaders meet, the models differ. In the Daley-Kendall version, both spreaders become stiflers. The Maki-Thompson rules convert only one spreader into a stifler; the other continues spreading.
•All other interactions (ignorant-ignorant, ignorant-stifler, stifler-stifler) have no effect on either party.
These rules make no sense! I don't think they bear any resemblence to what actually occurs. Additionally There should be rules based on previous encounters - such as:
if the last interaction was ignorant/stifler and current encounter ignorant/spreader ignorant remains ignorant.
spreader/stifler both remain as is unless previous encounter was also with oppisete type.
spreader/spreader should result in two spreaders - not a spreader stifler pair and certainly not two stiflers!
things like that.