The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #81532 Message #1494498
Posted By: PoppaGator
27-May-05 - 03:10 PM
Thread Name: harmony vs. melody
Subject: RE: harmony vs. melody
True enough, Michael, there are also probably some songs where only a "careful" harmony is appropriate.
For example, in certain modes, you should never inject a third because you'd have to choose either the major third or the minor third, and the song "wants" that ambiguity to be preserved; however, it might be perfectly acceptable to sing a fifth above the melody, or to sing a "drone" on the tonic note.
For some usually-unaccompanied songs, injecting a second voice can be problematic not only because of the harmony-vs-unison issue, but also because the tempo/rhythm is purposefully, um, vague. Perhaps "unstructured" would be a better word...