Wine and Whiskey?! What a silly analogy! Yes we do like unaccompannied singing but we also like accompanied singing and unaccompanied tunes. What's wrong with mixing them - it seems to me that some people have climbed up on on their high horses and can't see the ground from where they are, they certainly aren't listening to any of the arguments. Do they really want to live in a world where tunes are in one venue and songs in another? I don't! Vive la difference!