Q you said that Max Hunter didn't take credit for this song I have to differ just a bit.That is one reason this thread was started.I sang this the other night (the one I learned from Lulu Belle and Scotty back in the 1930s)at one of our gigs and my fiddle player said he knew the tune but the words he had on an LP were different.Of course I didn't believe him for as far as I knew at that time L&S were the only ones I'd ever heard do the tune.To make a long story short I went to his home and he had a Max Hunter LP he puchased in the 1970s and this tune was the first tune on the CD so I have to assume he did take credit for a song he rearranged