So, GUEST 1947:we should excuse the captured terrorists because it's OUR fault that they are a terrorist. Gimme a break.

troll: welcome back.

Clint: I would welcome your comment on this scenerio: Omar is captured in Afghanstan after setting off a car bomb that kills or wounds American troops plus several Afghans. He is brought to Gitmo for questioning. I believe it is your point that he should either be tried or turned loose.    If he is to be tried, with what should he be charged? What American law did he break? If he is to be turned loose, turned loose where?

DougR