The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #82215   Message #1539840
Posted By: Azizi
11-Aug-05 - 12:00 AM
Thread Name: BS: 'there is no Iraq military solution'
Subject: RE: BS: 'there is no Iraq military solution'
See this Wed Aug 10th, 2005 Daily Kos 'diary' by Sharon Jumper,
a veteran and the mom of a soldier.

Military Experts Say It's Time To Cut Our Losses in Iraq

Following are some excepts from that diary:

"General Odom says bluntly, "We have failed," and "the issue is how high a price we're going to pay - less, by getting out sooner, or more, by getting out later."...

"Another vietnam veteran, former CENTCOM Commander and Bush emissary to the Middle East, General Tony Zinni has many of the same concerns and sees paralells with Vietnam:

"Obviously there are differences" between Vietnam and Iraq, he says. "Every situation is unique." But in his bones, he feels the same chill. "It feels the same. I hear the same things -- about [administration charges about] not telling the good news, about cooking up a rationale for getting into the war." He sees both conflicts as beginning with deception by the U.S. government, drawing a parallel between how the Johnson administration handled the beginning of the Vietnam War and how the Bush administration touted the threat presented by Iraqi weapons of mass destruction. "I think the American people were conned into this," he says. Referring to the 1964 Gulf of Tonkin incident, in which the Johnson administration claimed that U.S. Navy ships had been subjected to an unprovoked attack by North Vietnam, he says, "The Gulf of Tonkin and the case for WMD and terrorism is synonymous in my mind."

Likewise, he says, the goal of transforming the Middle East by imposing democracy by force reminds him of the "domino theory" in the 1960s that the United States had to win in Vietnam to prevent the rest of Southeast Asia from falling into communist hands...

..."My contemporaries, our feelings and sensitivities were forged on the battlefields of Vietnam, where we heard the garbage and the lies, and we saw the sacrifice," he said at a talk to hundreds of Marine and Navy officers and others at a Crystal City hotel ballroom in September. "I ask you, is it happening again?" The speech, part of a forum sponsored by the U.S. Naval Institute and the Marine Corps Association, received prolonged applause, with many officers standing."

-snip-

This diary is followed by comments from other bloggers, some of whom are also veterans of the USA military.