The Folk Music Index lists three recordings, by Bradley Kincaid, Vernon Dalhart and the Williams Family (from Arkansas). It lists it as Laws E18 - Lamkin, Marjorie/Robison, Carson. The DT listing noted by harpgirl sez From Traditional American Folk Songs, Anne and Frank Warner Collected from Frank Proffitt, 1941 note: A song by this title was copyrighted in 1925 by Carson Robison, Shapiro, Bernstein.(notes by Mr. RG!)

So we have multiple author credits, tallying up it seems to come to two votes each for Lamkin and Robison, one each for Andrews, Shapiro, and Bernstein.