Which means, in short, that Roger got an answer that did not please him. That's all.

Posting answers under questions works for me, but Roger does not like it. Note that these questions have to do with Mudcat editorial policy, so posting the answer as an editorial comment seems perfectly appropriate. Personal opinions are another matter, but Roger is not requesting my personal opinion. What he defines as my personal opinion is another matter.

But Roger doesn't like where I put my answers, so he thinks that means it's wrong.

-Joe Offer-