Thanks Neil.

And Thank you Moonchild. To me the success of this thoughtful thread can be measured by the number of posters here giving their opinions without any curt "Why'd you start this thread in the first place?" comments. Often followed by reminders that the subject (or subjects) had been dealt with in the past.

I think we can all see that Mudcat is a constantly changing community, with new members arriving daily, older ones dropping out, and in some cases, former Catters coming back for a look-see.

A couple of months ago I noticed some threads asking for information on songs that were being discussed when I first came here over a year ago. I have to admit I was a bit annoyed. "Look up the old threads" I thought. After a few minutes I realised, that it's the "here and now" that forms a great part of Mudcat's attraction. Most people want to know what others are thinking "right now". That means current active members. I totally understand that, and if it means giving someone some info or an opinion that I've already given once (or more) before, so what? We're here to have fun, learn and educate..and hookin' new people into the world of folk music is still a kick for me.

Along with that, there will also be new threads questioning: balance, appropriate topics, political issues, and yes, even religious practices....just 'cause their will always be NEW PEOPLE coming along. Some will be shy, some will be aggressive, but Max built this "and they will come".

Mudcat is (and will be) fine. If you have ANY doubts, just go to any general forum on the "net". You'll quickly find out why you chose to be a "folky".

Rick