The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #75355   Message #1605144
Posted By: Dave'sWife
14-Nov-05 - 08:48 PM
Thread Name: 10 Nov 1975 -- Wreck of Edmund Fitzgerald
Subject: RE: 10/11/75 -- Wreck of Edmund Fitzgerald
In THIS THread:

RE: Origins: Puzzle:Edmund Fitzgerald and Bobby Sands

It was stated that the antecedent for the tune may have been a song called 'Spancil hill'. Anybody know anything more about that?

Lots of folks assume that 'Back Home in Derry' preceded TWOTEF but in other threads, people have shown that Lightfoot's song came first. Still and all, the melody seems too traditional to be original.