Why should Woodward's prior knowledge of Plame's identity blow Scooter's indictment away? The fact remains that her ID was still generally a SECRET, unknown to her own family members and friends, and certainly unknown to the general public or the broader press at large. The fact that Woodward knew it didn't make it general knowledge -- after all, he knew the identity of Deep Throat for decades before anyone else did. So Scooter could easily still have been a meaningful leak, and still clearly lied to Fitzgerald. I don't see that Woodward is germane to this issue, really.