Michelle,
Where do you live? I run into a few knuckleheads here in Michigan but mostly the drunks stay in their camps and only damage themselves. I still say go with the bowhunters and tell them your problems; they'll take care of it. I have a small group I let hunt my 160 and they treat it better than I do, and they've become good friends as well. They come to hunt the gun season too and keep the riff raff away. The trick is to make sure they know this is long-term and will continue to be available if they take care of it