Mudcat crashed on June 13th this year, and as Jon said, some data was corrupted. So posts made before then can appear jumbled. Some threads seem more badly affected than others. As you noticed, the Search can find the right thread, but will take you to a completely wrong post. There are also places where there is doubling up - links at the top of threads and photos are two I have noticed.

These things are not the best, but they are working on the problem. As far as I'm concerned - these days I'm just happy if Mudcat is up!

Jenny