The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #86772   Message #1616658
Posted By: McGrath of Harlow
29-Nov-05 - 04:51 PM
Thread Name: BS: Grammar Police: eats shoots and leaves
Subject: RE: BS: Grammar Police: eats shoots and leaves
One reason for the grocer's apostrophe and so forth can be that someone in a hurry has made a mistake. The other one, which I suspect is very widespread, is that the cunning grocer puts in the mistakes deliberately, knowing that every now and again a couple of pedants will be walking past, notice the error, notice the notice, and a purchase will be prompted.

As for possessive apostrophes: "They add absolutely nothing to sense or clarity" but "If you get marginal cases where the meaning could be ambiguous..." (Paul Burke). In other words that first bit is not actually true.

George Bernard Shaw huffed and puffed about this, and insisted on the offending apostrophes being removed from stuff he wrote.