The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #86789   Message #1616829
Posted By: GUEST,.gargoyle
29-Nov-05 - 09:10 PM
Thread Name: Songs in movies. Wrong key joke?
Subject: RE: Songs in movies. Wrong key joke?
Wow...interesting observation!

Joybell, please expand upon you insight, epiphany, true-pitch.

I do not (two progarms perhaps a year, by will, and maybe six a year if the holidays with inlaws DEMAND) watch video, TV, or go to the movies.

This observation "could" become a "reason" to view a few more....while I can transpose into any key....I still cannot ALWAYS determain (other than the big five) the key "by ear."

If someone declared

B

and a sax was present....of course it is B-flat.

This thread has the promise of becoming one of those "MUDCAT GREATS!!!" found only in the .org

I would like to read more. Your thread is a perfect example of a musical thread that should not be given the 24-hour AX-of-EXTINCTION...but this thread should be placed in a third area (OK - below the "below the line") a THIRD ZONE where "serious business" is discussed....and the "chit-chat" of "shine-ola" and "happenings" and "MP3" is left to the mewing, fawning, audiophiles of a lesser-calling...that should use the "Schat-Room."

Let threads like these - run for a week. Some of our "best" (on subjects like this) are not available for comment more than once a week...and in some cases once a month.

Sincerely,
Gargoyle