Fiddler / Andy,
It wasn't my intention ( or Terry k's ) to make you look silly - the subject still causes arguments in pubs and clubs.That's my take on it - so you could still be right!!
I tried to find the thread re that "Do" at Guiseboro ( Gillies spelling) to see if you are at that bash on the 10 th which would be an execellent excuse for a pint.

Terry I'm struggling to accept your Cook scenario - I was sure he was born Marton - then went to school in Great Ayton - ( the tiny village school building still being there ) i.e. not the Friends School which used to be on the Village Green.

Looks like a case for Sherlock !!!

Cheers Betsy