I guess it comes down to how you want to use it. My 20 gig iPod is for my whole collection so all the CDs, tapes, LPs can stay in the loft. And my whole music library is managed on the laptop, so for example if a particular song is being discussed on Mudcat, you can find and play all the versions you own instantly.

I see above that people like the iRiver, but it's only got 1 gig so is definitely only suitable for keeping a few selected tracks.

And the cost difference is just that - £80 for 1 gig versus £200 for 20 gig.

regards, Terry