I think it's very presumptuous for both of them to say what they did about "God's punishment", and I am not trying to defend that at all. My post was in response to this part of your initial post...

Or should this be titled, "white's stay out." ?

Whether or not New Orleans would be a better city with a Black majority, or a White majority seems a bit irrelevant to me. The people who were living there prior to Katrina, both Black as well as White, should be the first to have the opportunity to return.