It's a pretty simple pattern-- Roger objects to Mudcat policies, especially as they pertain to him. He starts thread after thread on some old aspect of a long-running rant, instead of simply living with the reality of the place which includes Joe Offer doing the job Max gave him to do.

It doesn't work, but Roger does it over and over again. He must simply want the attention. He snags new people into it each time who think that they can actually explain something to him or persuade him through debate. Roger doesn't want explanations, nor-- I agree with you Mmario-- debate. He wants to posture about free speech in a place that allows him the free speech to do it.

In any event, his view is not up for debate. It always boils down to a point in the FAQ he thinks ought not apply to him or that he thinks ONLY applies (and unfairly) to him. I've never seen one of his "positions," yet, that didn't have a clear answer in the FAQ.

~Susan