The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #90797   Message #1725431
Posted By: JohnInKansas
23-Apr-06 - 02:11 PM
Thread Name: black and tans back in the news
Subject: RE: black and tans back in the news
As noted by weelittledrummer and by Azizi, Duke Ellington's Black and Tan Fantasy most likely referred to persons of mixed race, and had nothing to do with the British/Irish lore. It may have been a sort of "social commentary" at the time, but the significance of that seems lost now.

Although Ellington probably played it as a straight instrumental (and it's quite danceable) I've heard that a lyric was written for it, but I've never been able to find one.

It does seem perhaps to be somewhat suspect as "not politically correct," as – so far as I've been able to find – it is omitted from all recent fake books or other compilations of Ellington songs. No notations, no discussion – apparently just because of the title.(?)

It appears on a few recordings, but they're mostly out of print and considered "collectibles," so they're on the expensive side. It's a great song, and it seems it must have been of significance musically; but has some "changes" – as I remember it – that I've never been able to quite work out. I've searched, rather casually, for it for several years without finding anything useful.

It was a fairly popular "high school band" number as recently as about 1955-7, and perhaps my trouble with it is the result of playing it with clarinets who were always a bit out of tune; but it seems to have completely disappeared now.

I wonder why. Is it something I'd want to know, should I ever find it and want to play it?

Maybe those two words just don't play well together.

John