The current policy seems to be to let some attacks stand if they are part of a discussion but it seems that that is just making it hard for you guys. The lines are to hard to draw and to other people looking on the lines seem arbitrary. My suggestion would be to delete all personal attacts from everyone then tighten things up to the point where people learn where the boundries are and they learn not to mix attacks with discussion, then to loosen thing up from there. But I don't guess you moderators have enough manpower for that.