I've been having some difficulty with this one. I guess it would depend on how "Icon" is being defined for the purpose of this thread.

Here's some definitions from Websters...


3 : an object of uncritical devotion : IDOL

I'm not touching this one.


4 : EMBLEM, SYMBOL [the house became an icon of 1860's residential architecture -- Paul Goldberger]

I think, if there is any one person who symbolizes all of what the Mudcat is and has ever been, good as well as warty, it's Bruce Olson and all of his various personas.


But if it's just about who we particularly like, I'm with Bobert on this one.