The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #91101   Message #1731352
Posted By: Jim McLean
01-May-06 - 02:24 PM
Thread Name: Origins: Donald Macgillavry
Subject: RE: Origins: Donald Macgillavry
The best version, in my opinion is by Alastair McDonald whom I recorded and produced in the late sixties. I'm afraid I find that LP, The jacobite Rebellons on Topic) by Ewan and Peggy to be the worst I have ever heard. The combination of his nanny goat voice with pseudo Scottish accent and Peggy's whine is extremely off putting, to put it mildly.