The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #91224   Message #1735250
Posted By: beardedbruce
08-May-06 - 08:21 AM
Thread Name: BS: Again?
Subject: RE: BS: Again?
Bobert,

" No one can prove that going back in history would 100% change a situation today... Heck, you can probably find some laung cancer patients who smokes three packs a day who might have gotten lung cancer even if they had never smoked.. Can you prove that??? Well, logic says you can't... But what we do know is that there is a corrilation between smoking and lung cancer...

Same with Iran of today... Heck, maybe the US would have endorsed the Saudi Plan (which they never did) and not invaded Iraq and the Saudi Plan had been accepted and Iran, by virtue of being a supporter of the Plan (which promised Isreal security, BTW) might, ahhh, have decided to buck the rest of the Arab world and not gone along with the program??? Very unlikely... Just as unlikely that the guy with the 3 pack a day habit wouldn't have gotten ling cancer if he had never smoked???"


In spite of the CHARTER of Hamas, AND the realities of the last 58 years, and the PRIOR statements of the Iranians?


YOU are correct- All the Arabs would have changed everything about what they believe, how they have acted in the past, and admitted they have been lying for 60 years, just so you can have a solution.

Right- I do not see any support for your conjectures.

If I state that the UN will tell both sides to go back to the 1924 borders, and live with it, would YOU agree that the Arabs would accept that? They were offered far more in 1948, and did not agree to it.