I'd opt for an Annual fund drive, meself with follow-up PMs to those who don't respond. Sometimes, even the most well-meaning supporters need a reminder... or may be able to give later, but not at the time of the Fund-raiser.

I'd also opt for The Simpler The Better. I don't need an umbrella or a tote bag, Or a photo of Max in a Santa Clause suit. The more complicated it gets, the more work it takes and the more potential for spending some of the money that is raised in order to reward people.

I'd also opt for anonymous giving. (No, not you alone, Anony Mouse.) If someone wishes to announce how much they are giving as an incentive to get others to give, that's fine with me. I would just hope that it doesn't become institutionalized to the point where people who are on a limited income feel that there contribution is too small to make a difference, and don't give at all. The loss of income might be small, but the feeling of not belonging because of financial limitations should be avoided at all costs.

Once this thread rambles along for awhile (before it hits 400 posts, hopefully) I'd recommend that there be a concise, short list of proposals to vote "yea" or "Nay" on so that we can get moving on this.

Jerry