"As for Shimrod's message, there really isn't enough anti-MacColl prejudice at present! If anyone disagrees, then please provide a summation of what the war deserter Miller actually achieved!"

Silly question really (from a silly and embittered, failed rock star I would guess). MacColl's record of achievements is too well known for me to list them here (listen to any of his many recordings or look at the songs in the 'Ewan MacColl Songbook' for starters).

Speaking personally he provided me with some of the most exciting musical experiences of my life (I got into his singing in my late teens and long before I knew that there was any controversy surrounding his name) and he introduced me to the ballad repertoire through live performances and the 'Long Harvest' set of LPs that he did with Peggy Seeger. I was also privileged, in my early twenties, to attend one of the weekend singers' workshop sessions, that he used to run, also with Peggy Seeger, and he convinced me there that I too could sing. Although I may not be the best singer in the world I consider that Ewan provided me with the confidence to give it a go. My singing provides me with an important artistic outlet in my life and through my participation in the world of traditional song I have made many good friends and have met many fine people.

I don't believe that there is any question at all about Ewan's public achievements but he was also an inspiration to people like me and considerably enriched our lives - now that's a real achievement!!