The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #93493 Message #1801054
Posted By: Greg B
03-Aug-06 - 09:12 PM
Thread Name: Traditional music and copyright
Subject: RE: Traditional music and copyright
All else aside, many collectors and artists have had some major stones to claim copyright on all and sundry. Collectors like the Lomaxes have in one breath claimed that they simply took down the words and melody of traditional songs and published them verbatim (to get their living), then turned right around and stuck a 'c' within a circle next to same.
To me, that's just legalized theft of public property.
Same with some of the Clancy Bros. stuff...applying 3 chords and a melody line with improvised harmonies to something that had been 'owned' by Ireland for generations is the stuff of shady business managers, and does the artists themselves no credit whatsoever.
I think we're through that period to a great extent...the one where someone can add their 5 percent and claim it as their own and drag someone into court for singing it.
Arrangement is one thing, but most of this stuff was pure transcription!