The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #94005   Message #1820400
Posted By: The Fooles Troupe
27-Aug-06 - 10:27 PM
Thread Name: BS: Israel used cluster bombs
Subject: RE: BS: Israel used cluster bombs
"I'm beginning to see why you chose your handle"

Failed subtle ad hominen - read my web page to see real reason why.
:-)


"since you are intimating that you HAVE some cluster bombs and you are making a not so veiled threat."

Only a REAL fool would believe that! :-) Failed intimidation on your part - nice to see you trying to use what is between your ears though. Keep practising.


"I'm sure MI5 and the FBI would like to know YOUR address if they don't already have it."

I wouldn't be surprised if they do, even though I have never left my native shores. In fact I would be proud to be on file.

After all I KNOW I was on film in the 'Uncle Joh' days in Queensland, because I observed the unmarked police car filming everybody who used to go th the La Boite theatre - obvious proof of a hard-core-pinko-homo-nutter-commo!


""Israel clearly committed a war crime by dropping cluster bombs on civilian targets""

Just someone's personal opinion really, you SHOULD be able to work that out!


"Have the Israelis used suicide vests packed with ball bearings yet?"

Not aware of that - but Israeli citizens have used machineguns to attack civilians praying in mosques - the subsequent result of THAT was several years of attacks on Israeli civilians...


"nor have you established that the targets were civilian. Geneva Conventions STATE that the use of a hospital for offensive military operations MAKES it a military target. "

The Geneva Conventions were in place before WWII - why is that much historical WWII war footage of battles for towns show the battle taking place in civilian areas, houses, schools, etc?

Why did the Germans attack Stalingrad? Why did the Russians attack Berlin? Because THAT's the ground that both sides wish to possess.... - nobody in a real war waits for the umpires with their little flags to put everybody in the buses and take them to the playing field - rules are fine things, no doubt, but once the real shooting starts, all rules are off except 'make some other poor bastard die for HIS country'. Any intellectual wafflings are just irrelevant.


"Statement, without any arguement or proof- no validity established."

That's pretty common round here - and since most 'proofs' are really 'beliefs', it doesn't get us anywhere useful anyway.


"Even if you were correct that Hezbollah used these areas as launching points for their rockets, that doesn't give Israel the license to blow up the hospital anymore than cops have a right to shoot someone being held hostage because the perpetrator is using him as a shield while firing on them."

!!!!
:0