The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #94349   Message #1825703
Posted By: Azizi
02-Sep-06 - 10:07 PM
Thread Name: Hymn-tune popularity contest
Subject: RE: Hymn-tune popularity contest
I suppose the choir loft is dusty because these tunes are old?

Thanks for cluing me into the fact that St. Anne's is the same tune as "Our God, our help in ages past". Is that the same as tune as "Oh, God our help in ages past/our hope for years to come/our shelter in the stormy blast/and our eternal home?"

I hope so 'because I voted for it just because I had no idea what that St. Theodulph song sounds like.

But maybe that St. Anne's song doesn't have the tune I think it does and the other song has a tune I do know.

Maybe I should go back and vote for St. Theodulph just to make my vote even.

Should I or shouldn't I?

St Anne's versus St. Theodulph? Which has the best tune?

How the heck do I know???

Oh woe is me! Where's a midi when you wanna hear one?

What?! Me wanna hear a midi?!! What in the world was I thinking????!

Okay. Okay. I've returned to my senses.

Hallelujah, for that close call

And may the best dusty tune win.