"But how can our forum currently make any informed judgement?"

Informed judgement would seem to mean "make all information about who did what and their reasons public"..... ????so some of us can consider, argue, bitch, complain, debate, harangue, recriminate, suggest, condemn, praise, ....and generally choose up sides over what is 97% minutiae and trivialities, and which will STILL need to be ruled on by administrative staff anyway?????

Read my lips...no, wait...read my typing... **THIS IS NOT A DEMOCRACY!!!** We don't GET to vote on every decision made by moderators and their supervisors. "Informed judgement is not relevant!!"

Members have several privileges..not 'rights'.

Thank you for your attention.