The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #94891   Message #1843869
Posted By: beardedbruce
26-Sep-06 - 01:38 PM
Thread Name: BS: (recognizing Israel) too much to ask?
Subject: RE: BS: (recognizing Israel) too much to ask?
Let me see...


640,000 Palestinians flee from what becomes Israel, while numerous others stay and become Israeli citizens. No Arab nation will absorb them, even though the state of Jordan was specifically formed to be the "Arab Homeland" of Mandate Palestine.

Meanwhile, 820,000 Jews are driven out of Arab nations, and all are settled in Israel.

Now the Palestinians demand the land of Israel, for the 640,000 who left. By MY calculations, the Israelis should demand 1.3 times the area of Israel from Jordan, for THEIR refugees. Just about the size of the Entire West Bank, which under pre-WWII rulings was to have been a Jewish Homeland.


So, given the sacred "right of Return" the Arabs support, Israel is entirely justified in annexing the ENTIRE West Bank. Any Arab settlers there can go back to the Arab Homeland, Jordan.